https://dfid.blog.gov.uk/2012/02/29/start-them-young/

Start them young!

Ian sitting on the floor in a classrom
Ian back in infants class

Can you remember starting school? I have vague recollections of going to St. Margaret’s CoE Infant School, Durham in the early 1970s with my elder brother, when free school milk was still provided in little glass 1/3 pint bottles. Leading my eldest daughter as a toddler into Clapham Junction Asda Creche is a much more vivid memory: no tears, she didn’t even look back!

There is much debate about how formally to structure pre-school education and when to start – some Scandinavian countries don’t attempt to start teaching kids to read until the age of seven, but this doesn’t stop them excelling when they are in their teens. What is not disputed are the benefits of some kind of reasonable quality early childhood development (ECD), especially for poorer children from families that are not able to stimulate and nurture them appropriately.

World Bank research has estimated that entrenched poverty contributes to the fact that 61% of under 5′s in Sub Saharan Africa ‘do not grow and learn to their full potential’. Save the Children Fund’s ECD programme in rural Gaza Province in Mozambique has run since 2008 and an evaluation of its impact makes for interesting reading. It identifies specific benefits to children attending even a very low-cost programme, estimated to cost only US$2.5 per child per month (that’s less than a Big Mac!). Families also gain: elder siblings have more time to attend school and mothers to engage in productive work.

Schoolchildren in Zimbabwe
Early learners, Southern Zimbabwe

Here, across the Mozambiquan border in Zimbabwe, ECD classes for 4-5 year-olds have been spreading rapidly – despite the hard economic times of the past decade. With almost no funding from government, primary School Development Committees and local communities have been struggling to pay for ECD classrooms, equipment and teachers.

Recently I visited a small rural primary school in Matabeleland South, with 290 primary and 35 ECD students. The heat outside was oppressive, but unlike some schools, at least the bare classrooms offered a relatively cool place to learn.

The unqualified ECD teacher Mrs Margaret Nyathi had taught since 1995 at the school. Despite being a single mother of seven, she acts in effect as an unpaid volunteer, receiving only around US$10 a month. A levy of $5 per term for ECD pupils was set, but few parents paid this. Despite her services being undervalued, Mrs Nyathi is clearly committed to the young children and led them professionally in games and songs. It was humbling to join in, sitting cross-legged on sacking on the dusty floor. 

A teacher holds open a book
ECD teacher M Nyathi

The Zimbabwe government is struggling to raise the salaries of formally qualified school teachers – in unionised pay negotiations a ‘living wage’ is much debated. Mrs Nyathi receives only a small fraction of this, despite putting in similar levels of effort and devotion to her young wards.

Few nations, even in developed countries, can afford free schooling from pre-school to tertiary studies. What is becoming much more evident in low income countries is the long-term effectiveness of ECD provision. Policy makers continue to face strong pressures to publicly fund post-basic education for better-off families – the sad reality is that many children of the poor drop out long before completing primary education, and so the cycle of poverty continues.

3 comments

  1. Mighty Ihesiulor

    hello Mr. Ian, you have been a great facilitator in the Education sector, though i would love to read more of your recent deeds. Sub Saharan Africa and Asia have victim- children to basic education and need to be sustainably tackled. The Millenium Declaration is hopingl going to be achieved with a “miracle” going to be done, the DFID and other multi- lateral are embracing a quota inside this proposed miracle, but need more facilitators like what you have done.

    one other issue i want to talk about is that to tackle one problem eg. Education, we should consider synonymous issues that are directly or/ and indirectly related to thier focus. An example of an issue is the relationship between education and WASH ( water, sanitation and hygiene). I will rest my case at this point, till next time. Thank you.

    Reply
  2. Ian Attfield

    Many thanks for your encouragement Mighty!

    I couldn’t agree more that combining WASH is vital to get the intended benefits from education.

    The next phase ofthe Zimbabwe ETF will be supporting schools in this area, hopefully via school grants programme where communtiies decide there specific needs.

    Reply
  3. Nurper Ulkuer

    Dear Ian,
    Many thanks for this vivid reflection on a pre-school programme in a small village in Zimbabwe. You have painted the picture so well about how government struggle to supply these settings, and how communities struggle to keep them open.

    It is sad that ECD is not yet a funding priority for governments, nor for donor agencies, including DFID.

    Further, I fully agree with your observation that “publicly funded” post-basic education serves ONLY better-off families – while many children of the poor drop out long before completing primary education, and so the cycle of poverty continues.

    Yes it is a “sad reality” for us all… we need to be more vocal for making sure that poor children come to school with basic learning competencies, stay, learn and move on to a school that makes sense for them..

    I would love to see more blogs like yours, and DFID championing for ECD as an important priority to fund publicly..

    Best regards..
    Nurper Ulkuer,
    Sn. Adviser – ECD UNICEF NYHQ

    Reply

Leave a comment